Why are weapons different?

Over at B/X Blackrazor JD discusses how to make weapons different without making the combat a mess.

My two groups have been playtesting a system where all weapons do the same damage, with two-handed weapons roll two dice and pick the highest. Players liked the fact that they characters could pick any weapon without caring for the effects, and having machete-wielding, shuriken-throwing magic-users totally rocks. Simple design and great style is win.

Anyway, after a few sessions we started playtesting rules for weapon-specific rules, similar in scope to what JD proposes; here’s the list we currently use:

  • maces, war-picks and unbalanced, top heavy weapons: +2 to hit against armoured opponents (and equivalent like dragons). Also appropriate for crossbows, axes and the like.
  • axes and unbalanced, top-heavy blades: once per round, if the wielder’s melee attack fells an opponent, an additional follow-up melee attack can be carried out. Also appropriate for maces and swords.
  • flails and chains: the wielder’s opponent does not benefits from shield bonuses against the wielder’s attacks.
  • swords and long blades: +1 to DEF against a single melee opponent. Also appropriate for spears and staves.
  • spears and polearms: if the wielder haven’t attacked in a round and is being attacked in melee, the wielder can opt to preempt the attack with his round’s melee attack.
  • daggers and very small weapons: really easy to conceal (2+ on a d6).

Players really like it because the character customization impacts in a greater way in fights. Also weapons have been changes in the middle of really critical fights (a scene quite cool in movies that I’ve never seen before in RPGs).

Advertisements

The Internet wants to know what's your opinion on this. Leave a reply.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s